Push On/Off with Rotary Dimming compatibility

  • I've not seen any posts mentioning the Dimmer2 working with rotary switches. Is it compatible?

    My existing wall switches are Push On/Off with Rotary Dimming modules from https://www.varilight.co.uk/dimmers/v-pro.php - and I'm not having much look with them working so far. What button type configuration needs to be set in the Shelly app?

    The existing setup is 2 way wiring with a dimmer on one wall and a straightforward on/off push button on the other wall.

  • Unfortunately, two dimmers won’t work together at one light, whatever dimmer type it would be. Thus, your plan will not work. You’ll have to replace the rotary dimmer with a simple two way switch to implement dimming with Shelly. Or - much better - replace the rotary dimmer AND the two way switch with push buttons. This allows user-friendly dimming with up and down buttons.

    „Habt Geduld. Alle Dinge sind schwierig, bevor sie einfach werden!“ (aus Frankreich)

    „Nothing in life is to be feared, it is only to be understood.“ (Marie Curie, 1867-1934)

    „Es reicht nicht“, rief Schiller, „Gedankenfreiheit zu fordern, man muß auch denken können, sonst fordert man Gedankenlosigkeitsfreiheit und die ist die Freiheit zur Dummheit, welche wiederum die schlimmste Unfreiheit überhaupt ist!“
    (Aus „Besuch aus Weimar“ von Gert Heidenreich, Schriftsteller, *1944 in Eberswalde)

  • If you still want to use a rotary switch, you could also use a special 0-10V rotary switch and a Shelly 0-10V dimmer.

    https://www.shelly.com/en-gb/products/product-overview/shelly-plus-0-10-v-dimmer

    elektroman:~#

    Mein Zoo: 15xShelly2.5, 7xShellyPlugS, 4xShellyDimmer2, 2xShelly1PM, 8xShelly1, 2xShellyi3, 1xShellyPlus i4, 2xShellyFlood, 2xShellyDoorWindow2, 2xShellyButton1, 2xShellyButton, 2xSOnOff4CH, 1xSOnOff2CH, Nanoleaf, Meross, Govee, Tado, Tuya, Xiaomi, SwitchBot ...

    Raspberry's, OpenHAB, Pi-hole

  • Unfortunately, two dimmers won’t work together at one light, whatever dimmer type it would be. Thus, your plan will not work. You’ll have to replace the rotary dimmer with a simple two way switch to implement dimming with Shelly. Or - much better - replace the rotary dimmer AND the two way switch with push buttons. This allows user-friendly dimming with up and down buttons.

    There is only 1 rotary dimmer involved, the other switch is a simple on/off in the 2-way setup.

    Replacing one rotary dimmer with some push buttons on the wall face plate of 4 switches isn't ideal - creating more work and cost for a retro fit.

    So just to clarify, the Dimmer2 SW input doesn't support variable rotary dimmer switches at all?

  • Dieses Thema enthält 2 weitere Beiträge, die nur für registrierte Benutzer sichtbar sind, bitte registrieren Sie sich oder melden Sie sich an um diese lesen zu können.